Python 3, Punktzahl = 4/3 = 1,33… (N = 4) Punktzahl = 1,4 (N = 7)
Update: Brute-Force-Suche in "statischen" Lösungssätzen implementiert und neues Ergebnis erzielt
Ich denke, es kann weiter verbessert werden, indem nach dynamischen Lösern gesucht wird, die Gewichtungsergebnisse für weitere Entscheidungen verwenden können.
Hier ist ein Python-Code, der alle statischen Löser nach kleinen n Werten durchsucht (diese Löser wiegen immer die gleichen Münzsätze, daher der "statische" Name) und die Anzahl der Schritte im ungünstigsten Fall ermittelt, indem er einfach überprüft, ob die Messergebnisse nur eine übereinstimmende Münze zulassen in allen fällen eingestellt. Außerdem werden die bisher besten Ergebnisse und die frühen Pflaumenlöser protokolliert, die gezeigt haben, dass sie definitiv schlechter sind als diejenigen, die zuvor gefunden wurden. Dies war eine wichtige Optimierung, ansonsten konnte ich mit n= 7 nicht auf dieses Ergebnis warten . (Aber es ist eindeutig immer noch nicht sehr gut optimiert)
Sie können gerne Fragen stellen, wenn nicht klar ist, wie es funktioniert.
#!/usr/bin/env python3
import itertools
from functools import partial
def get_all_possible_coinsets(n):
return tuple(itertools.product(*itertools.repeat((-1, 1), n)))
def weigh(coinset, indexes_to_weigh):
return sum(coinset[x] for x in indexes_to_weigh)
# made_measurements: [(indexes, weight)]
def filter_by_measurements(coinsets, made_measurements):
return filter(lambda cs: all(w == weigh(cs, indexes) for indexes, w in made_measurements), coinsets)
class Position(object):
def __init__(self, all_coinsets, coinset, made_measurements=()):
self.all_coinsets = all_coinsets
self.made_measurements = made_measurements
self.coins = coinset
def possible_coinsets(self):
return tuple(filter_by_measurements(self.all_coinsets, self.made_measurements))
def is_final(self):
possible_coinsets = self.possible_coinsets()
return (len(possible_coinsets) == 1) and possible_coinsets[0] == self.coins
def move(self, measurement_indexes):
measure_result = (measurement_indexes, weigh(self.coins, measurement_indexes))
return Position(self.all_coinsets, self.coins, self.made_measurements + (measure_result,))
def get_all_start_positions(coinsets):
for cs in coinsets:
yield Position(coinsets, cs)
def average(xs):
return sum(xs) / len(xs)
class StaticSolver(object):
def __init__(self, measurements):
self.measurements = measurements
def choose_move(self, position: Position):
index = len(position.made_measurements)
return self.measurements[index]
def __str__(self, *args, **kwargs):
return 'StaticSolver({})'.format(', '.join(map(lambda x: '{' + ','.join(map(str, x)) + '}', self.measurements)))
def __repr__(self):
return str(self)
class FailedSolver(Exception):
pass
def test_solvers(solvers, start_positions, max_steps):
for solver in solvers:
try:
test_results = tuple(map(partial(test_solver, solver=solver, max_steps=max_steps), start_positions))
yield (solver, max(test_results))
except FailedSolver:
continue
def all_measurement_starts(n):
for i in range(1, n + 1):
yield from itertools.combinations(range(n), i)
def next_measurement(n, measurement, include_zero):
shifted = filter(lambda x: x < n, map(lambda x: x + 1, measurement))
if include_zero:
return tuple(itertools.chain((0,), shifted))
else:
return tuple(shifted)
def make_measurement_sequence(n, start, zero_decisions):
yield start
m = start
for zero_decision in zero_decisions:
m = next_measurement(n, m, zero_decision)
yield m
def measurement_sequences_from_start(n, start, max_steps):
continuations = itertools.product(*itertools.repeat((True, False), max_steps - 1))
for c in continuations:
yield tuple(make_measurement_sequence(n, start, c))
def all_measurement_sequences(n, max_steps):
starts = all_measurement_starts(n)
for start in starts:
yield from measurement_sequences_from_start(n, start, max_steps)
def all_static_solvers(n, max_steps):
return map(StaticSolver, all_measurement_sequences(n, max_steps))
def main():
best_score = 1.0
for n in range(1, 11):
print('Searching with N = {}:'.format(n))
coinsets = get_all_possible_coinsets(n)
start_positions = tuple(get_all_start_positions(coinsets))
# we are not interested in solvers with worst case number of steps bigger than this
max_steps = int(n / best_score)
solvers = all_static_solvers(n, max_steps)
succeeded_solvers = test_solvers(solvers, start_positions, max_steps)
try:
best = min(succeeded_solvers, key=lambda x: x[1])
except ValueError: # no successful solvers
continue
score = n / best[1]
best_score = max(score, best_score)
print('{}, score = {}/{} = {}'.format(best, n, best[1], score))
print('That\'s all!')
def test_solver(start_position: Position, solver, max_steps):
p = start_position
steps = 0
try:
while not p.is_final():
steps += 1
if steps > max_steps:
raise FailedSolver
p = p.move(solver.choose_move(p))
return steps
except IndexError: # solution was not found after given steps — this solver failed to beat score 1
raise FailedSolver
if __name__ == '__main__':
main()
Die Ausgabe:
Searching with N = 1:
(StaticSolver({0}), 1), score = 1/1 = 1.0
Searching with N = 2:
(StaticSolver({0}, {0,1}), 2), score = 2/2 = 1.0
Searching with N = 3:
(StaticSolver({0}, {0,1}, {0,1,2}), 3), score = 3/3 = 1.0
Searching with N = 4:
(StaticSolver({0,1}, {1,2}, {0,2,3}, {0,1,3}), 3), score = 4/3 = 1.3333333333333333
Searching with N = 5:
Searching with N = 6:
Searching with N = 7:
(StaticSolver({0,2}, {0,1,3}, {0,1,2,4}, {1,2,3,5}, {0,2,3,4,6}), 5), score = 7/5 = 1.4
Searching with N = 8:
Searching with N = 9:
(I gave up waiting at this moment)
Diese Zeile
(StaticSolver({0,2}, {0,1,3}, {0,1,2,4}, {1,2,3,5}, {0,2,3,4,6}), 5), score = 7/5 = 1.4deckt den besten gefundenen Löser auf. Die Zahlen in {}Klammern sind die Indizes der Münzen, die bei jedem Schritt an der Wägevorrichtung angebracht werden müssen.